
Hyundai Motor Group, already struggling with weak domestic demand, faces concerns that its recovery could be delayed by what critics describe as excessive union demands.
Hyundai Motor is grappling with weak sales in Europe and production disruptions caused by domestic strikes, while its union continues to push for an extended retirement age and more new hires without proposing ways to share the costs.
Critics say Korean labor unions should also help strengthen competitiveness, noting that even German automakers are struggling with high costs and halting production or considering plant closures at home.
According to industry sources on Tuesday, Hyundai Motor’s global sales in the third quarter of this year totaled 920,710 units, a decrease of 11.3% from the same period last year. Revenue also fell by 3.4% to 45.1102 trillion won.
This was the result of shrinking global demand compounded by production disruptions at domestic plants. In response, Hyundai Motor lowered its annual sales target from 4,158,300 units to 4 million units and cut its investment plan for the automotive division by 180 billion won.
In particular, in Europe, sales declined despite overall market growth. From January to September this year, the European auto market grew by 3.7%, but Hyundai Motor’s sales dropped by 9.2% to 415,000 units.
This was influenced by intensified electric vehicle competition due to the entry of Chinese manufacturers and sluggish sales of existing key models.
The consolidated net loss for Hyundai Motor Europe (HME), the company’s European sales subsidiary, over the same period swelled to 814.9 billion won, approximately 4.7 times the 172.1 billion won recorded in the same period last year.
While competition among manufacturers is intensifying overseas, production has been hampered domestically by strikes. The Hyundai Motor union carried out a cumulative 60 hours of strikes per work shift during this year’s wage negotiations.
With day and night production lines halted for a total of 120 hours, an estimated 55,200 units of production were disrupted, according to industry estimates.
The estimated revenue loss, calculated based on vehicle sales prices, exceeds 230 billion won. Plant utilization rates also declined. Hyundai Motor’s domestic plant utilization rate from January to September was 93.6%, down 8.1 percentage points (p) from the same period last year. Production volume decreased by 9.8% from 1,387,804 units to 1,252,440 units.
Other affiliates are also facing similar cost pressures. Kia experienced a total operating profit reduction factor of 577 billion won in the third quarter due to rising raw material prices and the aftermath of the Middle East conflict. Hyundai Steel’s operating profit decreased by 6.5% from the same period last year, and its operating profit margin was only 1.5%.
Furthermore, if the union simultaneously pushes through demands for extending the retirement age, converting workers to regular employees, and expanding new hires, the burden on workforce management and labor cost control will inevitably increase.
Regardless of the intent to address income gaps in old age and resolve youth unemployment, resources and volume are needed to sustain increased employment, yet the union has not presented specific sharing plans through wage system adjustments or productivity improvements.
Aggravating market conditions
The risks of high-cost production bases have already been revealed in Germany. Volkswagen ended vehicle production at its Dresden plant last December, halting existing automotive production functions while converting the site into a hub for research and innovation.
Mercedes-Benz also halted additional investment in German facilities and began considering plant closures after negotiations to reduce labor costs hit a dead end.
With competition from Chinese manufacturers, sluggish demand, and high production costs overlapping, even domestic plants have become targets for restructuring.
Professor Lee Ho-geun of the Department of Future Automotive Engineering at Daeduk University said, “In a seniority-based structure where wages rise with years of service, extending the retirement age by five years without supplementary measures such as a wage peak system could significantly increase labor cost burdens.”
He said that if costs rise while profitability deteriorates, it may lead to companies becoming more aggressive in reducing labor costs through measures such as introducing humanoid robots.
“Going in the opposite direction while European manufacturers are undergoing restructuring could weaken long-term competitiveness,” he said. “Strikes aimed at pushing through such demands are not beneficial for workers themselves in the long run.”