The debate over the "white-collar exemption," which would allow high-income professionals to be exempt from working hours regulations, has resurfaced recently amid recommendations from Bank of Korea researchers and demands from the industrial sector. Companies are calling for flexibility in research and development, while labor groups express concerns about "free overtime" and overwork.
During a National Assembly Climate, Energy, Environment and Labor Committee audit in October, a lawmaker from the ruling party asked, "Are high-income professional managers not human beings?" The concern regarding long working hours is valid. However, a distinction must be made between unlimited labor and limited exceptions premised on compensation, rest, and individual consent. In fact, even the 52nd-hour weekly cap does not apply to workplaces with fewer than five employees. Regulatory gaps remain where protection is most needed, while uniform regulations operate where autonomy is required.
The starting point of this discussion lies in the nature of the job. Unlike tasks that follow a set process and schedule, jobs requiring high-level expertise, such as research and development, strategic planning, and business management, rely heavily on flexible time utilization.
In particular, in advanced industries, the speed of technological development is synonymous with competitiveness. According to Counterpoint Research, China's CXMT saw its global DRAM sales market share jump from less than 1% in 2023 to 9% in the third quarter of this year. A survey by the Federation of Korean Industries in July also found that 50.6% of advanced strategic technology companies cited flexibility in working hours for research personnel as their top regulatory priority. Research and development requires both intense focus to overcome obstacles and sufficient rest to foster new ideas. The current flexible work system has limitations in accommodating time utilization tailored to these characteristics.
Let us address some concerns and misconceptions. While the risks themselves are not misconceptions, the notion that all exceptions should be excluded because of those risks warrants reconsideration.
First, there is the claim that an exemption equates to "free overtime." The United States provides an overtime pay exemption for certain managerial and professional roles meeting specific criteria, but we have no reason to follow suit. We can maintain flexibility in time limits while recording actual working hours to preserve premium pay for extended, night, and holiday work. The core issue is not reducing labor costs, but resolving the reality where work is halted due to statutory time limits during critical phases of research and development. Reasonable compensation is also essential for attracting and retaining top talent.
Second, there is the argument that relaxing caps will fail to prevent overwork. However, protective measures can be adequately designed. Japan applies an exemption for high-income professionals based on individual consent, while mandating at least 104 days of leave per year and health protection measures. We can similarly mandate continuous rest periods, sufficient holidays, and health checks for employees working long hours.
Third, there are concerns about the indiscriminate expansion of exemptions. A high salary does not automatically imply autonomy; therefore, the scope should be limited to high-income professionals who have substantial discretion in job performance and time allocation. If a company unilaterally controls workload and working hours, no exemption should be permitted. Granting an exemption to those without decision-making power over their time is not autonomy, but an abandonment of protection.
Working hours regulations are a means to protect workers, not an end in themselves. The "sovereignty of time," or the ability to independently adjust working and resting hours, is also important. Protection should be strengthened for labor where it is most critical, while autonomy should be expanded for professionals with substantive choice. Uniform regulations that ignore diverse labor realities can constrain not only the sovereignty of time but also the competitiveness of companies and the nation.
