
Retail investors' enthusiasm for stock-themed exchange-traded funds (ETFs) has cooled. Not a single thematic product appears among the top 10 ETFs by retail net purchases in the second half of this year. Funds that had flocked to artificial intelligence (AI) and semiconductor themes in the first half have shifted to major U.S. indices and covered call ETFs.
According to KOSCOM ETF CHECK on the 18th, even when expanding the scope to the top 20 by retail net purchases as of the 17th for the second half of this year, there were only three stock-themed ETFs, all of which were leveraged products.
In the first half, five stock-themed ETFs ranked in the top 20 by retail net purchases. These included 'SOL AI Semiconductor TOP2 Plus,' which made the top 10, as well as 'TIGER Semiconductor TOP10,' 'TIGER U.S. Space Tech,' 'KODEX AI Semiconductor TOP2 Plus,' and 'KODEX AI Power Core Infrastructure.' Four single-stock leveraged products for Samsung Electronics and SK hynix were also included.
Index-tracking and covered call ETFs filled the vacant spots. Two new entries of each type entered the top 10 by retail net purchases in the second half: index-tracking 'KODEX U.S. S&P 500' and 'TIGER U.S. Nasdaq 100,' and covered call 'KODEX 200 Covered Call Active' and 'TIGER Dividend Covered Call Active.'
This shift is interpreted as a result of increased volatility in the stock market. Analysis suggests that investor fatigue has grown as Samsung Electronics and SK hynix, core holdings of thematic ETFs, have experienced sharp swings, falling 48% and 62%, respectively, from their June highs. Some bond-type ETFs, classified as safe-haven assets, have even outperformed stock-type ETFs in returns.
A researcher at a securities firm said, "Many investors who bought at the peak last July are still holding those positions." He added, "To recover their losses, they need to sell their holdings and switch to other products, but because the losses are so large, they are not trading at all."
Lee Jung-hwan, Managing Director of the Strategic ETF Management Division at Mirae Asset Asset Management, said, "Thematic ETFs have a structure that concentrates investment in specific industries, making them more volatile than the overall market." He continued, "In the first half, the upward momentum in AI and semiconductors was clear, but as leading sectors wobbled in the second half, investors naturally moved toward options with lower volatility." He explained further, "Indices like the S&P 500 or NASDAQ100 are diversified across hundreds of companies, allowing them to absorb shocks even when specific sectors fluctuate. In the case of covered calls, the monthly distributions help investors endure periods of market turbulence."
Experts advise using major index ETFs as a core asset class in portfolios and utilizing thematic ETFs on a supplementary basis. Lee said, "I recommend making U.S. major indices your core." He added, "A core-satellite structure is the most realistic approach: holding three assets—U.S. S&P 500, U.S. NASDAQ100, and U.S. Dividend Dow Jones—as more than 50% of your portfolio as the core, and layering themes you are confident in as satellites."