AI Automated Translation.

Font Size

Share

Top tax accountant's failure fuels 'professional obsolescence' debate… The courage to say 'no' is not tested on exams

Top tax accountant's failure fuels 'professional obsolescence' debate… The courage to say 'no' is not tested on exams

Interviews with seven current professionals on the 'professional obsolescence' debate
Unlike exams, real-world facts are often unclear, and responsibility is a burden
Simple task automation may reduce the number of jobs

On the 'professional obsolescence' debate/Graphic=Lee Ji-hye
On the 'professional obsolescence' debate/Graphic=Lee Ji-hye

"How to tell management, who wants numbers to look good, 'no,' and persuade them is not something that appears on exams."

Certified Public Accountant A answered this way when asked in an interview with Money Today on the 16th, "How do exams differ from practice?" He added, "Areas requiring judgment, such as revenue recognition timing and the size of provisions, must be concluded through consultation with management, audit committees, and regulatory authorities," noting that "while AI may excel at qualification exams, performing the role of a professional is a different matter."

The 'professional obsolescence' debate has intensified after it was revealed that the top scorer on this year's 63rd Tax Accountant Examination committed AI cheating. The argument is that since AI scored near-perfect marks on the first-stage tax accountant exam, where candidates' average scores are only in the 30th to 60 range, professionals can be replaced by AI. However, interviews with seven current professionals revealed that practice differs from exams in areas such as △verifying and validating facts, △bearing responsibility, and △formulating optimal strategies.

First, many respondents noted that while exam questions provide clear factual circumstances, real-world situations often involve incomplete facts, making verification and validation crucial.

Certified Public Accountant B explained, "Exam questions clearly present factual circumstances such as transaction details and the sequence of events," adding, "In practice, there are many complex situations where the facts themselves are unclear or the legal form of a transaction does not match its economic substance, requiring direct verification through interviews with personnel, contract reviews, and site inspections."

Tax Accountant C also stated, "Practice involves many unique cases specific to certain companies, making it difficult to derive correct answers based solely on laws," and added, "There are areas that tax audits rarely touch upon, and such field practices would be difficult for AI to learn."

AI smart glasses on sale at an eyewear store in Daegu city on the 16th./Photo=NEWSIS
AI smart glasses on sale at an eyewear store in Daegu city on the 16th./Photo=NEWSIS

Professionals also have the advantage of taking responsibility for erroneous judgments. Certified Public Accountant D said, "Most accountants are likely already using AI," but added, "Ultimately, the accountant's name is listed on the audit report, and if problems arise due to failing to properly verify AI responses, they bear responsibility such as damages and disciplinary action."

Furthermore, professionals can provide optimal solutions tailored to a client's situation. Certified Labor Consultant E stated, "The purpose of an exam is to get the correct answer to a question, but the purpose of practice is to provide maximum benefit to the client," adding, "For example, even if a client asks about the likelihood of winning or losing a dispute, a good labor consultant is one who can well explain that settlement is in their best interest."

While it was acknowledged that AI cannot completely replace professionals, common forecasts suggested that the number of jobs would decrease in the long term. The argument is that humans will handle complex tasks and final verification, while AI will take over simple bookkeeping, journal entry preparation, and searching laws and precedents. Patent Attorney F said, "The amount of work a single patent attorney can handle will increase due to automation of simple tasks," adding, "There is a possibility that the required workforce will decrease in the long term."

However, it was explained that recent declines in hiring are largely influenced by industry conditions rather than AI. In particular, new accountant recruitment at the Big Four accounting firms (Samil PwC, Samjong KPMG, Deloitte Anjin, and EY Han Young) decreased by 40% in three years, from approximately 1,300 people in 2022 to about 800 last year. This was explained as a result of the expansion following an increase in the minimum number of Certified Public Accountant qualifiers in 2022, which has gradually shrunk due to the recent economic downturn.

Chae Hyeon-pen, Representative Attorney and Tax Accountant at Pentagon Legal & Tax Accounting (President of the Korea Bar Association), argued, "Jobs centered on repetitive tasks will decrease, while the proportion of roles involving judgment and responsibility will grow," adding, "A permanent body is needed to regularly estimate the supply and demand of legal personnel, reflecting productivity changes due to AI."

"This article was translated using AI and may differ slightly from the original."