
Kim Hyung-tae, CEO of ShiftUp, has become embroiled in controversy over the use of generative AI. Facing criticism questioning how a creator could utilize AI, Kim (CEO) took a direct stance, asserting that the work was "created through hard effort."
The controversy began when Kim (CEO) posted videos on YouTube and X showcasing the next installment of 'Stellar Blade,' created with the help of AI. The video introduces the new protagonist, 'Ivy,' presenting the original soundtrack for the sequel, 'Stellar Blade: Blood Rain.'
The YouTube video surpassed 1.17 million views and received over 8,000 comments. While some comments expressed anticipation for the sequel, many pointed out the use of AI. Sarcastic remarks followed, such as "My RAM usage went up while watching this video." Despite the production team investing significant effort in character design and using AI only for movement, there was an atmosphere of intolerance.
As the controversy continued, Kim (CEO) personally responded to comments. When a user asked, "Can you hire talented artists instead of soulless AI slop?" he replied, "This character was created from head to toe by our talented artists and modelers through over a year of dedicated work." He added, "It was not created from scratch using AI. AI is used only to render the characters based on the data, designs, and craftsmanship we have developed."
Kim (CEO) is a first-generation game concept artist. Many characters born from his fingertips continue to serve as role models for countless people today. It is natural to be surprised and critical when such a top-tier concept artist uses AI. Since the popularization of AI, conflicts over how far AI should replace human work have persisted globally.
Kim (CEO) has long been a proponent of AI. At a press conference held ahead of ShiftUp's KOSPI listing in 2024, when asked, "Some gamers are not favorable toward the use of AI in game development," Kim (CEO) responded, "We will ensure that AI-generated results do not become products directly consumed by users." He further stated, "We are exploring ways to drastically improve efficiency in intermediate stages of development by leveraging AI's efficiency, and this will be integrated into our processes while maintaining our unique identity."
Earlier this year, he also told President Lee Jae-myung, "When games go overseas, the first ones players encounter are Chinese games." He added, "While ShiftUp invests around 150 people in a single game, China deploys 1,000 to 2,000. To compete with them, I believe everyone must be proficient in AI so that one person can fulfill the role of 100."
In the gaming industry, there are voices suggesting that Kim (CEO) is driven by a sense of mission. The argument is that if a concept artist of his caliber steps forward to utilize AI, it could accelerate its spread more quickly. In reality, many game companies today use AI in their development processes but hesitate due to fear of backlash. At one point, I asked an associate of Kim (CEO) about the meaning behind the company's name. He explained that 'Shift Up' refers to "transferring cells from a nutrient-poor medium to a nutrient-rich one when culturing Misaeng." Perhaps today, Kim (CEO) is in the process of shifting up the Korean gaming industry.
