
The Fair Trade Commission has effectively decided not to accept Korean Air's request to relax the obligation to maintain supply seats on the Guam route, where demand has decreased due to changes in travel trends and other factors. This is because the circumstances that arose are not those that occurred after the corrective measure imposing the seat maintenance obligation was issued by the Korea Fair Trade Commission.
The Korea Fair Trade Commission also announced that it will impose penalty payments for non-compliance and file criminal charges against corporations, including Korean Air and Asiana Airlines, for failing to fulfill the supply seat maintenance obligation on the 'Cheongju-Jeju' route.
On the 30th, the Korea Fair Trade Commission stated that it has submitted a review report (equivalent to an indictment by the Prosecution Service) regarding non-compliance with corrective measures and applications for modification of corrective measures related to the Korean Air-Asiana Airlines business combination.
The review report is a document recording the illegality identified during the investigation process by Korea Fair Trade Commission investigators and opinions on related measures. However, it does not bind the final judgment of the committee. A final judgment on the case will be made after future independent committee deliberations.
Previously, when approving the business combination between Korean Air and Asiana Airlines, the Korea Fair Trade Commission prohibited reducing the number of supply seats on 40 routes with concerns about competition restriction to less than 90% compared to 2019.
Problems arose on the Guam route. This is because passenger demand for Guam decreased due to infrastructure deterioration and changes in travel trends.
According to aviation statistics from the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, only three passengers boarded Korean Air flight KE2260, which departed from Guam and arrived in Busan on November 7 last year. Considering that a typical aircraft with 180 seats carries a total of six staff members, including the captain, first officer, and four cabin crew, the number of crew members was greater than the number of passengers.
In response, Korean Air requested that voluntary slot surrender be recognized as completing structural measures, and asked to lower the supply seat maintenance obligation standard from 90% compared to 2019 to 70%.
However, the Korea Fair Trade Commission did not accept this. The change in circumstances that could serve as grounds for modifying corrective measures must be those that occurred after December 24, 2024, when the committee finalized the corrective measures, but the decline in popularity of the Guam route had been evident prior to that.
Jeon Seong-bok, Director of the Business Combination Review Division at the Korea Fair Trade Commission, said, "The absence of a significant change in circumstances after (the finalization of the corrective measure) is the biggest argument for (the opinion to reject)."
Furthermore, based on data analysis, the Korea Fair Trade Commission believes that Korean Air only began managing supply seat ratios toward the end of the year, resulting in some flights with extremely low load factors. It was explained that when viewed over the entire year, there are other routes with lower average load factors than the Guam route.
Meanwhile, regarding the fact that Korean Air and Asiana Airlines supplied less than 90% of supply seats on the 'Cheongju-Jeju' route compared to 2019 from December 2024 to the end of last year, the Korea Fair Trade Commission included in the review report its opinion that imposing penalty payments for non-compliance and filing criminal charges against corporations are necessary.
Director Jeon stated, "We hope Korean Air will comply with the corrective measures more responsibly," adding, "We hope that there will be no further non-compliance with corrective measures and that they are well maintained during the compliance period."