JRL Global REIT lost a lawsuit filed in the UK regarding allegations concerning overseas real estate appraisal reports, which it had considered a prerequisite for normalization negotiations with creditors. With the voluntary restructuring program (ARS) negotiation period extended by one month last month, proceeding with bankruptcy proceedings is expected to be difficult.
According to foreign media reports on the 9th, the UK Commercial Court ruled on the 8th (local time) that JRL Global REIT lost its objection lawsuit against CBRE Loan Services, a representative financial institutional investor of the main creditor group, which had claimed that the existing appraisal report for Belgium's Financetower, a core underlying asset of the company, was prepared in a biased manner.
JRL Global REIT is a real estate investment trust (REIT) managed by JRL Investment Management. In April, it became the first domestic public REIT to file for corporate restructuring after failing to repay 40 billion won in short-term electronic commercial paper.
As a result, in May, the company suspended bankruptcy proceedings and entered into ARS negotiations with the management company and creditors to normalize the REIT. This process is being carried out with the goal of business normalization, minimizing damage to corporate valuation, and receiving court support for restructuring, with most stakeholders agreeing to cooperate.
Currently, the ARS has been extended for the third time. It was expected that discussions on normalization would resume after confirming allegations regarding the appraisal report for Belgium's Financetower by the local UK court.
The core issue of the lawsuit is the appraisal report prepared by global real estate services firm Jones Lang LaSalle (JLL). JRL Global REIT argues that during the preparation of this appraisal report, the list of tenant renewals was excessively reflected, and incentive costs that could be received when new leases were signed despite high renewal probabilities were written differently from reality.
However, the defendant in JRL Global REIT's lawsuit is not JLL, which conducted the appraisal, but CBRE Loan Services, a local representative financial institutional investor in Belgium. The Belgian local entity filed a lawsuit in the UK court against CBRE Loan Services, holding it responsible for failing to properly manage the appraisal process.
However, with the anticipated UK court ruling resulting in a loss, the future corporate normalization process is expected to be difficult. Resolving cash trap (cash trap), which hinders domestic creditor groups and investors, also seems out of reach. Cash trap refers to measures that tie cash flow under the control of the main creditor group. JRL Global REIT claims that after this measure, funding conditions in the capital market deteriorated rapidly.
It remains uncertain whether the court will extend the ARS again. If the company had won the lawsuit and the cash trap was lifted, negotiations among stakeholders could have proceeded smoothly, potentially leading to the cancellation of the bankruptcy filing application, but the market expects this to be practically difficult.
Regarding this, a JRL Global REIT official stated, "It is hard to accept that the court recognized the validity of the JLL appraisal despite criticisms from multiple perspectives and claims that it was substandard service below expectations." The official added, "Regardless of the ruling, we are smoothly conducting concrete negotiations with the Belgian Building Management Authority to extend lease terms for a long period, and are preparing various contingency measures, including negotiating financial conditions with reputable financial institutional investors to resolve the cash trap as soon as possible."
Meanwhile, regarding the outcome of this lawsuit, the Small Shareholders' Alliance stated that it judged the company's response to be inadequate and is reviewing various legal measures from multiple angles.
in STOCK
